santa cruz moms

A place for local moms to share information and meet new friends

I was very much looking forward to this new show. I was happy to see that there was finally going to be a show that addressed what so many moms are going through. What a HUGE disappointment the show was..where do I start?
I will start with the one positive thing..the comment the husband made about not being able to give is wife that "completeness". This hits exactly on the issue that I think so many stay at home moms face. While I love my kids and am thankful for the time I get to spend with them, at the end of the day I need to feel like I did something for me. I need to spend a little time doing something that I am passionate about that makes me feel like a little more than a chef, house-cleaner, chauffeur, referee, etc,. That is what feeds my desire to someday go back to work.

I hate that the show is promoted as asking what a mother "gave up" to be a stay at home mom. All that kind of thinking does is bring up the dreaded "mommy wars". I kind of feel like this has been a non issue lately, but am sure this show is once again stirring the pot. It brings us back to the discussion that moms who stay home gave up a chance for a succesfull career and set the feminists back a few years and working moms are not making the right decision in doing what is best for their family. Give me a break, that is just wrong. Women make the decsions that are right for them and their family and how dare the media continue to add fuel to this fire that one choice is "better" than the other. It is hard enough being a mom (working outside the home or not) we don't need to constant media influences to make us second guess the decisions we make.

I know this is a TV show and it is for entertainment purposes, but TLC usually seems a bit more on track. The huge black "SLSM" van..like mom was off being a secret agent...well that was just plain silly. I admit it, I like reality shows. I find a show like The Real Housewives of Orange County very entertaining. The lifestyle of these moms is just so far from the reality of moms out there that it makes for very good entertainment. I don't watch that show to learn anything that relates to my lifestyle, I watch it for fun. The Secret Life of A Soccer Mom was not exactly entertaining and did not teach me anything, all it did was make me angry.

Here is where I think the show really missed the mark..This mom was not living at her house for the week that she was working. She was not trying to get kids up, feeding them, dressing them, getting them out the door and then getting to work on time and then doing it all again in the evening. She was getting a full nights sleep, something she probably had not had in YEARS and knew the children were "safe" at home with their dad. That is not the reality of a working mom, is it?! Sure, that once again makes for good TV, but isn't it more important to show what it is really like for a working mom.

And here was got my blood boiling the most about the show.. I get that the show editing has to be done in a way to make it interesting to watch so will not even talk about the fact that she was forced to make the decision to go back to work in a few hours without having any discussions about salary, schedule, childcare, etc,. I have to believe that these conversations did happen, but would not make for good TV. But here is what could have almost redeemed the entire show for me. I would have liked to see the mom have a discussion with her employer about working part time. Couldn't she be a successful fashion designer 3 days a week? I would have liked to see the show focus more on the idea that moms can have it all. Wouldn't it be nice if the show worked with companies that do offer flexible schedules where the "job" of a mom is respected? Why continue with this idea that it has to be either or. Why do we have to make a choice?

3 Comments

Star Comment by Star on March 14, 2008 at 2:39pm
I agree wholeheartedly! I was also VERY disappointed about how they approached all of it and I felt that it was approached in a very flippant way instead of giving the subject the respect it deserves. I with the people from SuperNanny had made the show...they make a show about a very sensitive subject of parenting and people's feelings and families and how they were raised and yet somehow you feel like they are very respectful about the subject manner and you can actually learn from it. The only thing I felt good about with this show is that the host is pregnant. That is so rare and at least makes the statement that pregnant women can be beautiful hosts too even if they aren't supermodel Heidi Klum ;) Thanks for your thoughts and for sharing that you also were insulted by this show.
Pascale Comment by Pascale on March 14, 2008 at 4:50pm
I wrote a flaming thought process rant on my personal family blog about it. I was beyond infuriated with it. If I can figure out how to cut and paste maybe I'll post it in a comment here.
Pascale Comment by Pascale on March 14, 2008 at 5:05pm
Here is my blog entry that I cut and pasted:
So I watched the premiere of "Secret Life of A Soccer Mom" last night at 10 pm when I SHOULD have been sleeping (yeah, right) or catching up on work.... I sat up and watched stupid reality TV and vegged out (for once) while silently (or not so silently) cursing the producers of the show. Granted the premise is a good one and it puts media focus and the general public's attention on a very important subject matter. The idea behind the show is that they find a long time stay at home mom who gave up a lucrative career/dream/goal many moons ago when she decided to stay home and raise her kids. The women they choose for the show have most likely spent time working in their chosen field not to mention devoted a great number of years of training and education towards said career (specific degrees and schooling for said line of work). But they gave it all up when they became moms. So they take these women and tell the families that the women are going away to a week long spa reward and let the hubbies stay home and "take care of everything." And while everyone thinks the mom is getting pampered she is actually being given the opportunity to work in her desired (sometimes former, sometimes dream) field and gets to experience being a "working" mom and seeing for herself whether the grass is actually greener. Well it all sounds dandy but is hugely flawed. For starters, speaking as a working mom, I don't have the luxury pf getting whisked away to a hotel room during the week to get the job done and blissfully leaving behind all the huge obligations that come with family life like OH I DON'T KNOW... cooking, cleaning, homework, bath time, laundry, groceries, paying bills, driving kids around to school and various activities, dishes, packing lunches, meal preparations, and so on and so on ad nauseum! It's totally unrealistic to call her experience anything akin to that of a real working mom. The stress of the "working mom" involves the intense juggling act of a career intermingled with the hugely pressing and all consuming needs of children and family life and home life all jumbled into one big complicated package. So, taking her away from the chores and demands of her family, life, kids and responsibilities so she can focus exclusively on the "working" part of the "working" mom title does not encompass the reality of the situation by any stretch of the imagination. That said, it was truly inspiring to see this woman in the premiere fall so quickly and skillfully into her new "job" after being out of it for 10 years and doing a FABULOUS job at it despite being nervous, rusty and slightly out of place. She still did great and was commended on her ability to work quickly under pressure and multi task. Duh. Do you think she learned those skills from 10 years of sitting on a couch eating bonbons? Puh-lease. Is there no harder job than being a mom? Really now folks. Being a mom is the pinnacle of all the hardest jobs all put together!!

At the end of the show the mom is offered a full time position where she did her little week long stint and has just a few hours to make her decision about whether or not she will accept the job offer and if she does she starts in 2 days. Well, I have a bone to pick here too. Does anyone really give you a mere 3 hrs to make such a monumental decision. And where's the job interview part where the mom gets to ask the potential employer some pointed questions about pay, hours, benefits, sick leave rules etc... I would never accept a job offer from an employer without having seriously hashed out ALL those details IN WRITING. That's just plain old irresponsible to ask someone to answer that question so impetuously and with so little information about the nitty gritty of it all. That kind of decision will completely rock a family's world not to mention how to suddenly arrange for (GOOD and RELIABLE) childcare for your kids in a measly two days.... Come on people. Let's get back to the real world here! So, that part definitely upset me. It just wasn't fair to put so much pressure on making that decision so fast. And yet, still, despite my many many issues with the show, it's a subject matter that needs addressing, a subject matter that needs more attention. I think the whole stay at home, work from home, work outside the home issue is a fascinating one and more-so I think the LACK of choices and options out there for moms is APPALLING. I think it's reprehensible that most moms have only two choices, SAHM exclusively or work full time outside the home. And, realistically, most women have very little "choice" in the matter to begin with. When countries in Europe give women a full year of paid maternity leave and we give them 6 weeks of UNPAID leave, well, it just makes me want to puke. How dare we call ourselves a "developed" country?! Not so much...

So despite being so riled up, I'm a lame-o because I'm sure I'll be watching the next episode. Mostly because it helps remind me that within every SAHM out there resides some "secret" hidden talent and some real VALUE in this world outside of the tremendous value she has in the fact that she is raising kids in this crazy day and age. Clearly, there is no more important job out there. That is simply undeniable. But I also think it is hugely important that women tap into and put to good use their OTHER skills (and training or expertise) which combined with the skills they have acquired over the years of being SAHM' s (patience, multitasker extraordinaire, organizational genius, negotiating skills of a U.N. peacemaker...the list goes on and on!!!) well, that just proves what I have always known, that within all of us lies a SUPERHERO which, when given the chance to do so, and put to use ALL of our many multi faceted skills, we can truly live a rewarding, fulfilling and balanced life. Unfortunately, the opportunities are so few and far between and especially with how our society views long time SAHMs trying to re-enter the job market....Sigh. I do hope this show has one positive ripple effect which is to showcase what great talent resides in every SAHM.... And I suppose if the world isn't going to throw that opportunity in front of you (which it rarely does) then you should probably find a way to create it for yourself. Take a leap of faith IN yourself, FOR yourself. That, or apply to be on this show and show 'em what you are made of! Teehee:)


Ok, that was my rant. I'll be amazed if anyone reads through all of it, but I do this to help myself sleep at night, I have to let it all out and vent and process and so on!!! It's my therapy!

Add a Comment

You need to be a member of santa cruz moms to add comments!

Join this network

About santa cruz moms

Michelle Michelle created this social network on Ning.

Create your own social network!

© 2009   Created by Michelle on Ning.   Create your own social network

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy  |  Terms of Service